Burnham’s Brexit blancmange makes independence only way back to EU

The ongoing pantomime in Westminster over the UK’s relationship with the EU are reaching farcical new heights.

Andy Burnham has spent the past few weeks spinning faster than a weather vane in a west coast gale, confusing those with any lingering hope of Westminster reversing the catastrophic disaster of Brexit.

For Scotland, which was dragged out of the EU against its own emphatic democratic will, this latest chapter of Westminster double talk is as galling as it is predictable.

Watching Labour politicians addressing the fallout from Brexit makes a David Lynch movie feel like some light viewing.

So let us look at the timeline of the confusion emanating from Labour.

Over a year ago, before he became PM, Andy Burnham was telling a Labour conference fringe meeting that Brexit was a “disaster” and said “I want to rejoin the EU. I hope it happens in my lifetime“.

Yet, shortly after entering Downing Street, Andy Burnham said he would was remain firmly tethered to Starmer’s disastrous manifesto red lines.

A couple of months later and he’s again floating the notion that he would like to see the UK rejoin the EU ‘in his lifetimel‘.

Yet, within weeks, his administration slammed on the emergency brake, with No. 10 hastily briefing journalists that they want to “tap the brakes” on the conversation.

And by mid-November his capitulation was crystal clear as he declared: “I am not proposing that the UK considers rejoining the EU“.

This screeching U-turn was on full display during Prime Minister’s Questions on 18 November 2026, when SNP Westminster Leader Dave Doogan MP challenged Mr Burnham over his glaring contradictions – forcing the PM to reaffirm his commitment to Starmer’s red lines.

To describe Andy Burnham’s position as a muddle is an understatement – it is more like someone trying to nail blancmange to a wall while blindfolded and wearing boxing gloves.

He admits that Brexit has done more harm than good and that the deal is akin to the “emperor’s new clothes”, yet he stubbornly refuses to lift a finger to fix it. It’s like a doctor who diagnoses a broken leg, and then prescribes a sticking plaster and a brisk walk.

If the Prime Minister looks like a political acrobat caught without a safety net, Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra looks like someone who has been unceremoniously shoved off the high board into an empty swimming pool.

In a frantic scramble to appease Scottish voters who despise Brexit, Mr Marra executed a neck-twisting U-turn of his own.

Just weeks after publicly declaring that rejoining the EU simply wasn’t on the table, Mr Marra performed a desperate about-face, suddenly committing Scottish Labour to rejoining the EU.

With Burnham’s latest position, it is a humiliation of epic proportions, leaving Mr Marra looking like a ventriloquist’s dummy whose strings have been tangled by a clumsy operator.

No sooner had he tried to present himself as a bold European champion than his boss in Downing Street ruthlessly kicked the legs out from under him.

It makes it abundantly clear that Scottish Labour is treated as nothing more than a local branch office to be patronised, ignored, and brushed aside whenever it suits London’s political convenience.

This contempt for Scotland – even for their own party branches – is baked into the very foundations of the Westminster system.

The people of Scotland will not have forgotten the grand promises made during the 2014 independence referendum when the official anti-independence campaign swore that a “No” vote was the only way to keep Scotland in the EU.

Figures like current former Scottish Labour leader and now minister in Andy Burnham’s government, Lord Anas Sarwar, went onto the airwaves to guarantee voters that ‘No’ meant staying in the EU.

That guarantee turned out to be as firm as the aforementioned blancmange nailed onto a wall. Scotland was yanked out of the world’s largest single market against our will, landed with billions of pounds in economic damage, red tape, and labour shortages, and is now expected to sit quietly in the corner like an obedient child while Westminster politicians play Brexit charades.

Labour operates under the arrogant delusion that they can fool all of the people all of the time.

They offer up smooth-tongued rhetoric about ‘closer cooperation’ and being ‘bolder’, as if sprinkling a few warm words will somehow turn turnips into truffles.

When push comes to shove, the fear of Nigel Farage, Reform UK and the Brexiteers reasserts itself; reinforced by the knowledge that with the combined support of the Tories and Reform well into 40% in the rest of the UK, there is no guarantee of a stable return to the EU for the UK.

So Scotland is treated as an afterthought – a handy source of votes at election time, only to be taken for granted and forgotten thereafter.

The truth, laid bare by Andy Burnham’s backpedalling and Michael Marra’s humiliating public exposure, is that Westminster will never deliver for Scotland.

The illusions peddled by the anti-independence campaign in 2014 are dead and buried and this latest episode of Labour duplicity should serve as further proof.

If Scotland wants to return to the heart of Europe, unlock our true economic potential, and trade freely with the world’s largest single market, we cannot rely on the party machinery of a Westminster government that only looks after itself.

The only secure, prosperous route back to the world’s largest single market is through Scottish independence. It’s time to stop waiting for Westminster to fix a broken house it wrecked in the first place, and start building a better future on our own terms.