Suella Braverman’s Illegal Migration Bill will not work. It can’t “stop the boats”, and it utterly fails to address the chaos at the heart of the Home Office and the wider immigration system. Over a decade of degradation of the Home Office under the Conservatives has brought us to where we are today.
I watched with despair at the Conservative benches in the House of Commons, lapping up the toxic rhetoric from the Home Secretary, as she laid out the latest magical solution to resolve the so-called “invasion” of people crossing the Channel on rubber dinghies.
The Hostile Environment, with it’s “go home” vans was meant to have dissuaded people from coming to the UK. The Nationality and Borders Act, passed only last year was supposed to have a similar effect. It isn’t even fully in force, yet this next damaging piece of legislation will be the one to fix it. Third time’s the charm, so the Tories would have you believe.
The Tories Illegal Migration Bill won't fix the issue of small boats.
It's about stoking a culture war and demonising refugees.
— Alison Thewliss 🧡 (@alisonthewliss) March 16, 2023
The reasons people flee conflict and persecution are much more compelling than the barriers being put up by this dangerous legislation. People come to the UK for many reasons, including family links, the English language, experience of having worked for UK forces in Iraq and Afghanistan, and for the long legacy of empire.
There is no system for applying for asylum from abroad. People literally must have their feet on UK soil before they can make an application. They can’t hop on a plane, as they won’t be allowed to board without the appropriate visa. Safe and legal routes are few and far between.
The exception to this, of course, has been Ukraine. You won’t find Ukrainians amongst the Iraqis, Iranians and Afghans in rubber dinghies, because for them, there is a functioning safe and legal route. No one would grudge Ukranians this important route to safety, but having proven it works for this group of vulnerable people fleeing conflict, the UK Government really ought to establish routes for other groups who are equally at risk.
❌ The UK government's abhorrent anti-immigration bill is not only unworkable, Tories openly admit it is in breach of the Convention on Human Rights.
🤝 SNP MPs will oppose this inhumane and cruel bill, and stand shoulder to shoulder with those seeking safety in this country. pic.twitter.com/FC9DsE5ztx
— The SNP (@theSNP) March 13, 2023
In many of the cases I have dealt with in my advice surgeries, there are long delays for decisions on their cases. Some have waited for over a year in B&B accommodation for a decision, unable to get on with their lives and contribute as they dearly wish to do.
The various schemes the UK Government have proposed to tackle the issue are costing a fortune, sending hundreds of millions of pounds to the French Government, detaining people when they arrive here, and a costly and unworkable deal with Rwanda.
Investing more wisely in the boring work of actually processing cases would be a much better use of public funds. Allowing asylum seekers the right to work while waiting for a decision would also be better all round – for the people in the system, for the public purse, and for integration into our communities.
We can and must do better than the divisive language of the Home Secretary. The anti-racism march through the streets of Glasgow on Saturday gives me hope that there is another way of dealing with this matter, one which recognises that these are our neighbours and that refugees are welcome in Scotland.